Tue Feb 3, 2015
There are few delights that rival the skin of an excellent rotisserie chicken. Sure the juicy, flavorful meat is great, too, but the thin, browned skin that's crisped up in the bird's own slowly rendering fat is something I live for—it's the reason I got a rotisserie attachment for my grill in the first place. But three years after receiving that gift, I realized I was too hung up on specialty birds like Peruvian and mojo chickens; shamefully, I'd never cooked a single standard rotisserie chicken. I decided it was high time to right that wrong and set out to perfect the basics.
Rotisserie chicken doesn't have be more than a bird and heat. So I started out my venture the simplest way possible—one chicken and nothing more. I did, however, make sure it was a quality bird. I'm not big into organic everything, but ever since switching from those thick-skinned, yellow Perdue birds to more naturally raised chickens, I've noticed a jump in the quality of my final creations. I find these birds have a cleaner, more chicken-y flavor with skins that render and crisp more easily in comparison to the standard supermarket variety, both traits that I deem worthy of spending a few extra bucks on.
To make good use of my rotisserie space, I prepped another chicken to cook alongside the most minimal one I was using as a control. I didn't do too much to my second bird, just simply unwrapped it, patted it dry with paper towels, then placed it on a wire rack set in baking sheet and air dried it in the fridge overnight.
A side-by-side comparison clearly showed the air dried bird has much less moisture in its skin, which looks tighter and thinner than the chicken that was right out of the package. Air drying is a step I always take to get the best possible skin on wings, and thought it might be good procedure to follow to make great rotisserie chicken too.
I placed both birds on the spit and got them spinning over one chimney of hot coals that I evenly distributed into two piles on either side of the charcoal grate—this left the temperature inside the grill around 350-375°F. As they approached final doneness, it was clear that air drying was a smart move. On the left is the chicken that was taken straight from the package to the spit. Overall, the skin remained flabby and an unattractive pale orange and yellow.
On the other hand, the air-dried bird developed some beautiful browning, but it was spotty at best. There was a single streak of intensely browned and flavorful skin, which was something I was aiming for all over, not just in one area.
So I took those psuedo-failures and began taking steps to fix each one. For starters, more heat would produce more deeply browned skin, so I upped the amount of coals from one chimney to a chimney and a half. This brought the grill temp into the 425-450°F range. I also added a drip pan to between to coals to capture the rendering chicken fat after realizing what mess it made after the first go round.
Next I needed to make sure more of that rendering fat made it onto the skin, since that's where the flavor comes from. So I created fat escape routes by poking holes all over the chicken with a wooden skewer.
Finally, I gave the chicken a brushing of butter to further enhance the flavor of the skin and jump start the browning process. With all of these quick additional steps complete, I covered the grill and let the chicken cook until the meat hit 155°F in the thickest part of the breast.
The bird I uncovered was much more evenly browned with crisper skin, all within a cooking time that was 15-20 minutes shorter than my previous efforts. Everything added up to make a pretty damn juicy, tender, and flavorful chicken. It was certainly a great home attempt, but I knew I could do even better.
So I made one final bird, this time opting to season the chicken heavily with salt before air drying to act as a dry brine to further enhance the natural flavor of the meat and its juiciness. Everything else I kept the same and this one ended up being the best chicken to come off my rotisserie by far. I feared the dry brine would prove to be too salty, but that was proven unfounded—the extra salt was exactly what I'd needed to concentrate the flavor of the skin and meat.
Since this was my second bird that day, I didn't finish eating all of it, but I couldn't help but peel off all the skin and savor it while it was still warm and at its best (I pulled the leftover skinless chicken and made it into enchiladas later in the week). As good as this was, I was left thinking that even more heat might do the rotisserie bird more justice. You could get that effect with lump charcoal—which burns hotter than briquettes—or direct heat, although fatty flare-ups could make that problematic. I'm sure I'll give it yet another shot, but for now, I've found a method that is sure to cook up one truly excellent rotisserie chicken.
- Prep Time:
- 5 Minutes
- Inactive Time:
- 8 Hours
- Cook Time:
- 30 Minutes
- Total Time:
- 8 Hours 35 Minutes
- 2-4 servings
- 1 whole chicken, about 4 pounds
- 2 tablespoons Kosher salt
- 2 tablespoons butter, melted
- Pat chicken dry with paper towels. Sprinkle with salt all over outside and in cavity. Set chicken on a wire rack set in a baking sheet and place in refrigerator overnight.
- Using a skewer, poke holes all over chicken. Tuck wings underneath chicken and truss legs together with butcher twine. Run spit through cavity of chicken and secure with rotisserie forks.
- Light one chimney full of charcoal. When all the charcoal is lit and covered with gray ash, pour out and arrange the coals on either side of the charcoal grate. Place a foil pan between two piles of coals. Add an additional 1/4-1/3 chimney of charcoal on each pile of coals; let sit until all charcoal is lit and covered in gray ash.. Place spit on rotisserie and brush chicken all over with butter. Cover grill and cook at medium high heat until skin has browned and chicken registers between 155 and 160°F on an instant read thermometer inserted into the thickest part of breast, 30 to 45 minutes. Remove from grill and let rest for 10 minutes. Remove spit, carve, and serve.