Perfectly Grilled Ribeye Steaks
Last month I busted out my seldom used immersion circulator and sous-vided, then grilled some spectacular strip steaks. As much as those steaks were probably the most tender, perfectly cooked pieces of meat I've ever made, they were missing a deep, crusty sear and hint of smokiness that differentiates a great steak and spectacular one to me. So when an opportunity arose to cook a giant bone-in ribeye cut—also called a cowboy steak—I looked to the grill, and the grill alone.
Like those strip steaks, this ribeye came courtesy of Certified Steak and Seafood Company, with whom I'm trading my photography skills for meat—nothing wrong with getting paid in beef! I'm always a bit wary of meat I can't pick out myself, but so far Certified Steak has impressed me cuts that have had top notch marbling and ideal portioning for grilling.
On marbling, the ribeye comes with the best parts of the steer—the ribeye cap. This area around the edge of the ribeye has incredible intramuscular fat that makes it one of the most flavorful pieces of beef. If you can find a ribeye cap sold as a steak by itself, do yourself a favor and forget price and just get it. I've been lucky enough to have a few ribeye cap steaks in the past and all were some of the finest pieces of meat I've ever had.
On portioning, when grilling steak, you want to go thick. One-and-half to two inches is an ideal height for a cut—this thickness range is one factor that lets you achieve a medium-rare inside while also obtaining and thick, crusty sear. Thinner steaks just cook too fast, meaning you're likely going to need to sacrifice either doneness or the sear, a difficult choice I'd try to avoid.
The ribeye's immense amount of fat translates to maximum beefiness—a trait I wanted to let shine and not mask at all. So I went minimal with my preparation and only gave the steak a generous coating of salt and pepper 40 minutes prior to cooking—this duration gives the salt enough time to first draw moisture out of the steak, and then break down the muscle fibers so that the now-concentrated, flavorful liquid that was drawn out can be reabsorbed.
As much as fat and thickness help with getting a stellar final product, there's still no substitute for correct grilling. When looking at the ribeye specifically, I needed to ensure the entire monster cut would cook evenly over indirect heat first. The giant bone acts as an insulator, so that area cooks slower, which led me to position the steak so the bone was facing the fire—where there would be more heat—and the cap was as far away from the coals as possible—where it was coolest and would cook more slowly.
I cooked the steak in that position, flipping it every five minutes or so, until the internal temperature hit 105°F in the center of the steak. This was 15°F shy target 120°F for medium-rare, but that difference would be made up when searing the steak over the blazing hot, direct heat.
When the ribeye was done with its stint over indirect heat, it looked like this. You'll notice the area closest to the bone was already developing a bit of a sear since it was closer to the fire, while the rest of the steak was pretty pale. An important point of using the reverse sear method like this—when the steak is first roasted, then grilled—is that by now, most of the surface moisture of the steak is gone, allowing it to sear faster and more effectively over direct heat.
And sear it did! After only 15 seconds or so over direct heat, the ribeye was already looking crusty. For even cooking and the best sear, I flipped the steak about every 15-30 seconds, which also helped control the flare-ups— are inevitable nuisance with such a fat rich cut like the ribeye.
Once I had the thick, deeply browned crust I was after—it took about two minutes of cooking over direct heat—the steak had also reached an internal temperature of 120°F, which rose to its final medium-rare point of 125°F during its 10 minutes rest.
When I cut into this ribeye, I was greeted with a beautifully rosy interior from edge-to-edge with areas of wonderfully soft, luscious fat. This translated to one insanely tasty steak. The ribeye cap was the pinnacle of beefiness, but the rest of the steak wasn't too shabby—every bite I had was superb, even the ones that were all fat, which I personally love. Best of all, that interior was matched by an equally powerful exterior with a well charred, peppery crust. This is exactly what those sous-vide steaks were missing and why I would deem this ribeye to be closer to steak perfection. Luckily, I still have one more of these beautiful ribeyes laying in wait in my freezer, ready for me to try to up ante even more on what's already a winning recipe via the addition of smoke in my next go round, can't wait that!
Perfectly Grilled Ribeye Steaks
- Yield 4 servings
- Prep 5 Minutes
- Inactive 40 Minutes
- Cook 15 Minutes
- Total 1 Hour
- 2 bone-in ribeye steaks, 1 1/2 to 2-inches thick, about 1 1/2 pounds each
- Kosher salt
- Freshly ground black pepper
- Season steaks liberally with salt and let rest at room temperature for 40 minutes.
- Light one chimney full of charcoal. When all the charcoal is lit and covered with gray ash, pour out and arrange the coals on one side of the charcoal grate. Set cooking grate in place, cover grill and allow to preheat for 5 minutes. Clean and oil the grilling grate. Place steaks on cool side of grill with bone facing the fire. Cover grill and position top vent over cool side of grill. Cook steaks, flipping ever 3-5 minutes, until center of steak registers 105° on an instant read thermometer.
- Transfer steaks to hot side of the grill and cook, flipping every 15-30 seconds, until well seared and center of steak registers 125° on an instant read thermometer, about 2 minutes. Transfer steaks to a cutting board and let rest for 10 minutes; carve and serve.
You Might Also Like
Rob My mouth is watering. Do you have a favorite charcoal? Do you ever use lump charcoal? Love you techniques and pictures. Thanks
Josh @Rob I use Kingsford because it works great for grilling and barbecue, burns long, and is always consistent. Before I became an almost purely Kingsford man, I grilled a lot with Royal Oak lump charcoal and was happy with it.
Peg Your posts always have me drooling! I need to try steak this way. You are lucky you have a way to get really good meat. Keep on grilling and posting!
Marc Costco where I live has ribeye cap steaks. I think they're prime, too.
Rick Just can't get into reverse searing ............ I'll always sear first then pull off to indirect. The issue I've found almost every single time I reverse sear is ...... you lose too much moisture for my liking. Yeah they look great but they always seem to be too dry. On steaks like this 3 minutes per side then onto the cool side of the grill... covered and monitored to 125 degrees.
Craig Sad to report Certified closed up shop in early 2017.
Craig Sad to report Certified Steak and Seafood closed up shop in early 2017.